The dust has
just about settled on a bitter-sweet election night for progressives in
Scotland. On the one hand, we smugly watched the Blairite, austerity-light,
Scottish Labour party implode in a fireball of their own making. Beaten by an
anti-austerity message that inspired over a million Scots to send a message to
Westminster demanding change. Those who stayed up until the early hours,
popcorn out, were even treated to the result coming in live from South Thanet,
where Al Murray gleefully reacted to the news that the man beside him, Nigel
Farage, hadn’t managed to make it to the House of Commons either. However,
South Thanet was one of the marginal seats that the Tories needed to secure to
get a majority, and they did. The Conservatives thumped labour in a masterful
move on the chess board of British politics. David Cameron managed to keep
enough to the right to bandage up the bleed of voters to UKIP while painting an
apocalyptic vision of a Labour Government being controlled by Alex Salmond
behind the curtain, pulling all the levers of our economy until we had borrowed
and taxed ourselves to an early grave. The fact that that this worked so well
in England, and the remarkable shape of Scottish politics today, shows the
distance between these two countries is longer than the yellow brick road.Cameron’s Looming EU Referendum Threatens Everything We Believe In And More
The dust has
just about settled on a bitter-sweet election night for progressives in
Scotland. On the one hand, we smugly watched the Blairite, austerity-light,
Scottish Labour party implode in a fireball of their own making. Beaten by an
anti-austerity message that inspired over a million Scots to send a message to
Westminster demanding change. Those who stayed up until the early hours,
popcorn out, were even treated to the result coming in live from South Thanet,
where Al Murray gleefully reacted to the news that the man beside him, Nigel
Farage, hadn’t managed to make it to the House of Commons either. However,
South Thanet was one of the marginal seats that the Tories needed to secure to
get a majority, and they did. The Conservatives thumped labour in a masterful
move on the chess board of British politics. David Cameron managed to keep
enough to the right to bandage up the bleed of voters to UKIP while painting an
apocalyptic vision of a Labour Government being controlled by Alex Salmond
behind the curtain, pulling all the levers of our economy until we had borrowed
and taxed ourselves to an early grave. The fact that that this worked so well
in England, and the remarkable shape of Scottish politics today, shows the
distance between these two countries is longer than the yellow brick road.Not In My Name – The Struggle For Nuclear Disarmament
When the first nuclear bomb was detonated on July 16, 1945,
Robert J. Oppenheimer, one of the minds behind the construction of the atomic
bomb, quoted Hindu scripture from the Bhagavad Gita; “Now I am become Death,
the destroyer of worlds.” It was in that moment that Oppenheimer saw that he
had gifted humanity with the means to destroy itself. 70 years later, nuclear
weapons, the destroyers of worlds, remain situated in various countries across
the globe. Today, in 2015, there are around 16,000 nuclear weapons across the
planet, each poised to launch at any moment, ready to be deployed 24 hours a
day. We sit upon a perpetual knife edge, moments away from death, moments away
from total destruction.Statement on Stirling University Staff Redundancies
Stirling University SSP Society and SSP Stirling Branch
welcomes the Supreme Court’s decision to back the University and College Union
over Stirling University’s dispute with staff.
This has been a lengthy legal battle between University management and staff,
and we look forward to a final decision in favour of the employees who were
made redundant in 2009. This is a victory not only for the staff involved at
Stirling, but for university and college staff across the country, particularly
those employed under limited-term contracts.Capitalism, Socialism and the Environment
Growth is
how neoliberalism measures its own success. Every government, every bank, every
supermarket and every cafe wants to grow their profits from last year and more
importantly- out grow their competitors. This is Darwinist capitalism; where
the profitable survive and the rest fail. Free market economists argue that
this leads to ‘efficiency’- what it really leads to is low wages,
corner-cutting and the exploitation of natural resources to maximise profits
for the shareholders. As the Indian proverb goes, “Only when
the last tree has died and the last river has been poisoned and the last fish
been caught will we realise we cannot eat money”.
Coffee Without Caffeine, Change Without Change: A Socialist Critique of The SNP
Slovenian philosopher, psychoanalyst and cultural critic
Slavoj Zizek makes the point that in
today’s neo-liberal society contradiction is the norm, people are increasingly
offered “products deprived of their malignant property: coffee without
caffeine, cream without fat, beer without alcohol”. Zizek argues that this
combination of ‘pleasure with restraint’ is a fundamental part of the
ideological framework that shapes our everyday lives; and I contend in this article that the SNP’s
policies equate to a similar ‘beer without alcohol’, change without change
approach that we on the left must remain critical of.
![]() |
| The SSP boycotted the Queen's opening of Holyrood and took a republican oath in parliament. |
Nicola Sturgeon told the SNP conference at the weekend that
the SNP opposed the anti-democratic House of Lords, she also outlined their
commitment to oppose the renewal of Trident Nuclear Weapons and said that the
SNP wants to challenge the austerity politics of Westminster. As a socialist, I
welcome all of this and indeed support all of these measures, however that is
not the full picture. While the SNP are happy to slam the anti-democratic House
of Lords, they paradoxically support the divine right of kings and believe the
Monarchy has an important role to play in society, according to the First
Minster the Monarchy operates as "a model that has many merits". With Trident too, the SNP have made it clear
that they are against the immoral weapons of mass destruction and will always
vote against any renewal; and yet they support NATO, a nuclear military
alliance designed to assist US imperial interests across the world. The SNP
have tried to position themselves as an economically ‘progressive’ party
offering a different solution to the austerity agenda of Westminster, however
at a local level the SNP have, like all the other main parties, slashed budgets
of local authorities. The SNP’s economics in particular highlight their
attempts to appeal to all, to offer the ‘coffee without caffeine’ seeking
approval of folk like Bryan Souter while concurrently trying to appeal to the
working class voters who are sick of Westminster austerity. The SNP suggest that Scotland can both have a
‘competitive’ market-led economy and simultaneously have a Scandinavian-style
social democracy with a generous welfare state supporting all in need. Research
by Michael Keating and Malcolm Harvey in 2014 suggested that there would be
two, distinct paths an Independent Scotland could follow: either follow the
neo-liberal market economy (the Celtic tiger’ the SNP favoured until the crash)
or the social democratic model with high taxation, a strong welfare system and
state intervention. While Keating and Harvey never considered socialism as an
alternative their point was very much valid- there can be no socially just
neo-liberal economy, it’s against the very nature of the system. The SNP’s
plans for the economy in an independent Scotland was one of their weakest
arguments during the referendum campaign. They tried to appeal to the relatively
affluent ‘Tartan Tory’ SNP heartlands while reaching out to the working class
majority, (aided by RIC and the SSP) in the traditionally Labour heartlands of
Glasgow, Dundee and much of the central belt. The result of the referendum was
clear, the working class were much more likely to vote for Independence with
the better off most likely to oppose it. Yet too much of the SNP’s effort went
into appeasing the well off with ‘change without change’, ‘beer without
alcohol’ pledges- Yes we want Independence but we’ll keep the pound, we’ll keep
the Queen, we’ll lower taxes and so on- only to meet with failure. Despite the
attempts to win over and entice the Tartan Tory demographic they overwhelmingly
voted no (including Alex Salmond’s own constituents), while many working class
areas voted in favour of self-determination.
Another recent contradiction in the SNP message has been
their approach to the UK General Elections. The SNP, now with over one hundred
thousand members are set to do very well in Scotland as working class voters
rile against the long declining Labour Party that toxically stood shoulder to
shoulder with the Conservatives during the referendum campaign. Current polls
predict the SNP are to win at least 30 seats, some polls suggesting as many as
53. The SNP are pledging to be a voice for Scotland in Westminster and make
sure the Westminster establishment deliver on their ‘vow’ of more powers for the
Scottish Parliament. This is a reasonable position, however their approach to
the Labour Party has again been a contradictory one. Sturgeon has recommended
voters back the progressive choice: the SNP in Scotland, Plaid in Wales and the
Greens in England. However the SNP know that there will be only two parties
seeking to form a government, the Tories or Labour. The SNP as expected have
completely ruled out any deal with the Conservatives but have remained open to
some sort of ‘confidence and supply’ deal with the Labour Party. So while the
SNP, quite rightly, attack Labour in Scotland,
at a UK level they are willing to prop up a neo-liberal Labour government which
has pledged to have ‘iron discipline’ when it comes to deficit reduction. The
SNP of course pledge to put the ‘backbone’ into
a Labour government and have committed to force Labour away
from austerity. Yet the message is another coffee without caffeine solution: we
want the Labour Party wiped out in Scotland but we want to see a Labour-led
government in Britain. They want to play
a part in a government led by a party they are apparently vastly different from,
in a state they committed to dismantling. This really is taking the change
without change message to the extreme, May will tell how many Scots buy this
message.
So while we on the critical left welcome the demise of the
Labour Party’s hegemony in Scotland, we must be equally critical of the
currently buoyant SNP. We want a better Scotland, a fairer Scotland, with
social justice, democracy, internationalism and ultimately socialism at its
heart. The SNP like to think they offer this with their ‘beer without alcohol,
coffee without caffeine’ solutions, but the message we need to tell people is
it just doesn’t taste the same- change without change is not enough, we want the real thing.
Another Scotland is Possible, and we can’t leave it up to the SNP to deliver.
By Andrew Kinnell, Stirling SSP Organizer and Executive Committee Member.
Holyrood Shouldn’t Wait on Breadcrumbs From The Smith Commission; They Should Pass The Legislation That We Need To Create a Fairer Country
Stirling University SSP Co-Convenor, Hugh Cullen, critiques the current UK bourgeois democracy that is set up against the working class.
The racist former Tory MP, Enoch Powell,
once said; “power devolved is power retained”. While we should ignore most of
what is said by the man who once delivered his now infamous ‘rivers of blood’
speech, this couldn’t be more true.
London fought off the creation of a
Scottish Parliament for years and then only eventually allowed it because they
thought that it would kill the possibility of independence “stone dead”;
feeding the pesky Scots breadcrumbs to stop us stealing the loaf. Little did
they know that they would put Scotland on the brink of a democratic revolution
that would take the might of the British establishment to quell.
A quick analysis of the referendum results
paints a depressing picture. The 45% that voted Yes were the poorest in our
society, only defeated by a big turnout from the comfortable middle class and
the elderly who were duped into fearing change. The 45% were inspired by the
glimmer of hope that independence gave us; ready to take on the responsibility
of running our own affairs and determining our own future.
The Yes vote was a cry for help. A cry from
Scots who have been plunged into poverty by austerity they didn’t vote for, a
cry from Scots who have been let down by Westminster for generations, a cry
from Scots who don’t have a working class voice in politics.
While I am a democrat, I do not support the
bourgeois representative democracy that Westminster allows us. I will not choose
between one millionaire or another, in a first past the post race to fly down
to London to claim expenses. I will not allow corporations to manipulate
politicians into a race to the bottom over market deregulation and tax. I will
not support the privatization of our national assets. I will not sit down and
be quiet while our immigration policy is dictated by fear and xenophobia. I
will not let our environment be destroyed in the name of private profit.
The inconvenient truth is that this kind of
pseudo-democracy, propped up by the monopolised media, fails the working class.
It allows those who have power to tighten their grip and discourages public
debate outside the allowed spectrum. As Jim Sillars reminded us, on the day of
the referendum the Scottish people had full sovereignty in their hands – they
had to choose whether to keep that sovereignty, or hand it back to politicos in
Westminster.
We were deceived. Lied to by the British
establishment in their in their last great act to defend a declining empire. They
have failed on almost every count of the promises that they made and we won’t
let them get away with it.
When the SNP had the chance to nationalise
the railways and abolish the bedroom tax, they didn’t. They told us that they
didn’t have the power. Is this the same SNP who claim to ‘stand up for
Scotland’? As the parliament of Scotland, Holyrood has the mandate to execute
the will of the Scottish people. Real democracy is the working class taking
what they need, and who’s going to stop us?
We don’t need a second Edinburgh agreement
to have another referendum. We should call another referendum as soon as public
opinion suggests that a majority supports independence; an inevitability after
we get another government that Scots didn’t vote for and see the UKIP epidemic
sweep across England while we continue to reject racism.
Now, the UK mainstream media are hounding the SNP at the thought of them being a junior member of a government coalition and government figures are howling that the union is still at risk despite "the question being settled for a generation". A far cry from the coverage during the referendum where Scots were encouraged to engage in national politics, it seems we can only participate via 'establishment approved', unionist parties. Independence is deferred, not defeated. But will the 2016 Holyrood parliament get it done? It might involve breaking the rules and I don't think that the SNP are up for it.
Now, the UK mainstream media are hounding the SNP at the thought of them being a junior member of a government coalition and government figures are howling that the union is still at risk despite "the question being settled for a generation". A far cry from the coverage during the referendum where Scots were encouraged to engage in national politics, it seems we can only participate via 'establishment approved', unionist parties. Independence is deferred, not defeated. But will the 2016 Holyrood parliament get it done? It might involve breaking the rules and I don't think that the SNP are up for it.
By Hugh Cullen
Nae Passing! The Scots at The Battle of Jarama
SSP's Wullie Cunningham pays tribute to the Scots who faught in the Spanish Civil War.
![]() |
| International Brigade members captured after the battle of Jarama. |
Friday 27th of
January marked the 78th anniversary of the end of the Battle of
Jarama. For almost a month, the forces of Republican Spain held the route to
the Madrid-Valencia road the Nationalists sought to capture, though they were
unable to stop the fascists from crossing the river the battle is named after.
Among those fighting were 549
Scottish volunteers (proporitonally more than any other nation who had men join
the International Brigades) who were posted alongside the rest of the British
Battalion. The International Brigades were used as shock troops fighting the
brunt of the Nationalist advance. The Scots were among those to take and hold a
hill, named “Suicide Hill” due to the sheer number of losses felt by those
fighting there.
Among their numbers were men
from North Lanarkshire, most notably Jock Cunningham, a miner from Coatbridge,
who along with Frank Ryan, a founder of the Irish Republican Congress, rallied
the remaining members of the British Battalion to hold the line against
Franco's troops. In all, 11 men from North Lanarkshire laid down their lives in
the fight against fascism.
It is important that we never
forget these men in a world today where fascism is once again on the rise. Its
normalisation in many nations, including the rapid growth of UKIP (who while
not outright fascist, have attracted the support of many in the far right and
have some quasi-fascist policies) in the UK, would sicken those who fought over
seventy years ago to stop the same thing. As long as there is one fascist left
on Earth, we must stay vigilant against them and never allow another like
Franco, Hitler or Mussolini to rise.
As Woody Guthrie sang, we
must all remember the valley Jarama and the men who fought to protect democracy
in it, and continue their legacy in the fight to end fascism and
totalitarianism.
By Wullie Cunningham
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



